God, I hate mashed potato. Especially the way my husband cooked it, lumpy and sad, like the leftover washing in a basket that nobody hung out. He always cooked it first then let it sit there, in a ritual of neglect. I guess it was a lot like me. Something in the tedious backdrop of his life, something he occasionally thought about then forgot as soon as possible. Yep. Definitely a lot like me.
I watched him as he bought the two plates to the table, placing mine carefully in front of me. I adjusted my wheelchair slightly so I faced the table square on. He didn’t meet my eyes, and that was fine with me. My husband and I didn’t talk much these days, in fact, since my stroke, he hardly looked at me at all. It wasn’t hard to understand, I had none of my former beauty, with a face that sagged slightly and skin that had so many deep creases it looked like an origami square. But I was still his wife, and sometimes, it would have been nice to feel just a sliver of concern or affection.
As I picked up the fork to poke at the limp offerings on my plate, I sensed that he was studying me carefully without actually looking at me directly. How strange, but then again, no stranger than the awkward pretense of caring that bound us together. Although I was used to our silent, familiar dinners, this time, he surprised me by attempting some small talk.
“It’s been a little warmer than expected for this time of year, don’t you think? I’ve activated the sprinkler timers again – I think it might help the garden.”
I was chewing my green beans, carefully, trying to make sense of this sudden conversation. He continued to chat but still didn’t meet my gaze.
“I think I might pop down to that new nursery on Bigge Street. It’d be nice to have some more potted colour on the verandah.”
He continued prattling about plants and the garden but I wasn’t really listening. I was staring at him, trying to figure out what was going on. The dinner didn’t look any different except that the potato seemed more rounded, more lovingly placed. He certainly hadn’t made any special effort to spruce up – same old gnatty polo shirt loosely tucked into khaki pants with socks and loafers. Just my husband’s usual style, or lack of style if you wanted a more cutting assessment.
Two more minutes went on; I really didn’t pay attention to the conversation, just nodded my head and blinked when my husband stopped to take a bite. I noticed he had a folded-up piece of paper in the pocket of his shirt – it looked like a printout of the life insurance policy we’d filled out online two months ago. I could see the tip of the logo just peeking out from the pocket square. It was nice to have it done, I must admit, as a precaution against some terrible accident or tragedy. I didn’t contribute much in the way of finances – only my disability pension – but I certainly didn’t want my husband to struggle too much if I checked out too far in advance of him. And, as my husband had calmly explained, I would also be provided for if something unfortunate befell him. Fair enough, said I, filling in the check-boxes and putting my digital signature at the end of each page as he’d instructed.
There was something about that little flap of paper poking out that irked me this night. I could also smell the new cologne my husband had bought himself, wafting across the table from me and mixing with the salty-starch dinner smells in an unholy matrimony. He’d been wearing it ever since he’d started helping out at the Lyon’s Club a few months ago. It seemed like every Tuesday night now, he’d shower, shave, put on his least-gnatty polo shirt, and disappear until the brink of dawn. It was fine, I told myself. He deserves to go out and have a good time. Except that I knew the club had wheelchair access and well-appointed facilities for those with a disability. For those just like me who wanted to go out and enjoy themselves too.
Halfway through a mouthful of mashed potato, my husband remarked “ Mmmm, this mashed potato really hits the spot tonight. Nice and creamy. Go on and try it.” He gestured towards my plate and I narrowed my gaze, then instantly recovered. Whatever was going on here, I felt it best to play it cool, appear not the least bit interested.
“Well, you know,” I managed to splutter out, “I might save it up ‘til the end if it’s so good.”
“Oh, er,” my husband stammered before regaining his poise, “it’s better with the flavours all mixed in, you see.”
What flavours, I thought sullenly. Everything he cooked tended to taste like it had been drifting in sea-water for several days, already pecked at by seagulls.
I eyed the mashed potato suspiciously, scooping up a forkful of the peas and corn kernels dumped next to it like loose debris at a construction site. My husband seemed to be holding his breath.
As I chewed, the machinations of my mind churned and several mental pieces of a jigsaw puzzle started to join up in a fuzzy, then crystal-clear picture.
New cologne.
Regular nights away.
A new life insurance policy.
A burden of a wife who gives him nothing, but demands a duty of care.
An unnatural fixation with this evening’s offering of mashed potato.
I felt it before the actual words rattled themselves into my brain.
My husband has poisoned my mashed potato.
He wants me to eat it and then fade away from his life forever.
My throat felt dry. I swallowed then asked him for a drink of water. He acquiesced, disappeared into the kitchen, then returned with a glass of cool water. He placed it down and I drank it slowly, wondering idly if the consumption of water diluted the effects of poison.
It took me another thirty seconds to heap up my fork with mashed potato and slowly plop it into my mouth. I could see my husband’s shoulders relaxing, his innocuous conversation about garden plants starting up again. We finished our meals, and my heart grew heavy, the silence swirling around us like a lit fuse winding its way to the end.
He looked at me, eyes bright.
“You know I love you. I just…” He trailed off. I couldn’t fathom what words he might be reaching for.
I opened my mouth to speak but nothing came out. All I felt was emptiness, regret, longing. I had delivered a package of myself to my husband that felt so alien, so unwanted, and so removed from the woman he had married, he had not known what to do with it. And finally, finally, he had decided to throw it away.
I closed my eyes and said some kind of prayer – to whom, for whom, I did not know.
When I opened them, my husband was fiddling with his collar. A film of perspiration appeared just below his hairline. He looked at me, eyes wide as it became clear what had happened.
When my husband had retrieved a glass of water for me, I had switched our plates, rolling an extra sausage from my plate to his so it looked like a similar amount of food. We had both finished our meals and I had to agree, the mashed potato was particularly good tonight.
Three minutes later, my husband slumped forward, dead. I manoeuvred around to his side of the table and carefully prised the life insurance document from his shirt pocket. This would save me sifting through all those files on his computer; I never did care much for the technological way of doing things. In time, I might even check out those Tuesday nights at the Lyon’s Club my husband was so fond of attending. They even had mature-age singles nights there, I’d heard.
But one thing I would never do – I would never care to put one more scoop of that soggy, bland, too-cold mess of a vegetable known as mashed potato into my mouth ever again. Good riddance to that which has lost its flavour, is more dutiful than beautiful, and just takes up the space where something so much more delicious could actually be.
Latest posts by Neille Williams (see all)
- Friday Book Club - July 4, 2021
- A Mashed Potato Murder - October 25, 2020

Nice work, Neille.
Haha. Great story!!